After reading some of the comments
on the blog/forum The Singing Stage about the film Jersey Boy and it’s
transition from stage to film, I’m starting my own review series showcasing how
some of my favorite plays/musical transitioned well, or not so well, on film.
First up in the series, the
play/film “
Some Girl(S)”(not to be confused with the film and tv show Some
Girls). “Some Girl(s)”, written by Neil
LaBute, follows the character Guy(renamed Man in the film), a writer who is on the verge of getting married but before saying “I do”, he decides to revisit and make “amends” with few of the
women(some of whom have been the subjects of his writing) across North America
whom hearts he has broken years prior. On this journey he encounters 4(5 in the
film) from his past.; Sam his high school sweetheart, Tyler his former sex
buddy, Lindsay, an older married professor he had an affair with and Bobbi, the
one that got away. The film version stars Adam Brody as Man, Jennifer Morrison as Sam, Emily Watson as Lindsay, Mia Maestro as Tyler, Kristen Bell as Bobbi, and Zoe Kazan as Reggie, the younger sister of Man's best friend(and no, it's not a dog) Both of whom does not appear in the stage production. The screenplay was written by Neil LaBute and directed by Daisy von Scherler Mayer.
Production.
Kudos goes out to director Daisy
von Scherler Mayer for keeping the feel of the play alive, which was not easy.
“Some Girl(s) is a very complex play to transition into film. It uses just 4,
but very lengthy, scenes to tell the story. The film follows that same motif.
Mayer could have easily thrown in some scenes and flashbacks to help tell the
story like MOST directors would have done with a play like this*cough* Tyler
Perry *cough* For Colored Girls *cough*, but she didn't. She just let the characters tell the events of
the story through dialog. The only area in which the movie, production-wise,
fails to live up to the play is the creative way in which the scenes changed. Having
maids come in and act as if they are cleaning the hotel room while actually rearranging
it to indicate a new hotel/new city is replaced by random cut-scenes of Man in
and out of airports.
Guy vs Man

There has always been debate whether the main character was a “toxic bachelor or a misguided romantic? A
sensitive seeker or a sadist?”
Eric McCormack, of “Will & Grace” fame, portrays
Guy as douche-bag who is only meeting his exes to see if he has “missed out” as Bobbi points out in the climax of the play. In the film, lovable
Adam Brody plays Man as someone who actually seem genuine.
Watching, you feel sympathy for him. You actually root for him. Unlike in the
play, when the women begin to turn on him you actually feel sorry for him. You
feel as though he is in some form a misguided lover who actually means well
when he deserts the women he allegedly loves. Sounds crazy? But who could hate Adam Brody? The only time the viewer turns on
him is during his meeting with Reggie, (an alleged (see below) newly written
character for the film) a woman that Man “sexually assaulted” when she was just
a pre-teen. Other than that, Brody’s Man comes across as too nice. Too nice to
be guilty of the things coming out of these women’s mouths.
The Origins of “Reggie”
 |
| Zoe Kazan as Reggie |
Contrary to popular belief, Reggie
is not a new character written for the film. She was actually written for the
play but removed. Given the history between Man and Reggie, it makes a bit of
sense as to why it was a LaBute's better call to leave her out. The introduction of Reggie sends the story in an
entirely different direction. A dark road that did not need to be voyaged, even
though the scene is the most powerful of the entire movie. The quirky, yet exotic Zoe Kazan delivers the strongest
performance in the entire film. Her Parker Poser-like scene-stealer skills are superb.
She makes your heart quickly go out to Reggie, no matter how much sympathy you
have gained for the lovable Adam Brody Man. However, to make this guy a jerk is one thing, but to turn
him into a sex-offender is taking it too far.
As others have suggested, it would be better just turn the scene with
Man and Reggie into its own One Act play. As you can see via YouTube, a lot of college theatre students are performing the scene between Man and Reggie for assignments and exit-exams.
GRADE:
As A Film Standing on its Own: B-
As An Adaptation: A-
I took some points off for adding Reggie and for casting Emily Watson as Lindsey. Great actress, but she’s unbelievable. Unlike Fran Drescher(who originated the role on the American stage), Watson does not come across as a professional woman that would have an affair on husband with a colleague; a younger one at that.